Why do Financial Advisors discredit the FIRE Movement?

By now, many of you have heard about the Susie Orman interview by , where she denigrates the FIRE movement, and claims that you need $5M to $10M in order to even think of retiring.  While she has walked back some of those comments since the interview, she still appears to believe the FIRE movement is not ready for prime time.

She isn’t alone. Major finance sites like Barrons, Investment News and Market Watch have all published articles lately casting “shade” on t he FIRE movement. Heck, even Broke Millennial has issues with the movement. Yet all of their arguments appear to follow the same pattern – them emphasize the “RE” and not the “FI” portion of the argument. From my readings of the FIRE blogs, the “FI” portion is really what motivates folks and gets them moving.

Typically, the only folks I see in the movement working on the retirement portion of this are folks, like me, who are in our late 40s/50s and who have been able to check out a little early. Almost all the folks in the 20s, 30s and 40s of the FIRE movement are writing about what they are doing now that they’ve hit FI – and they aren’t standing still. Most have taken their side hustles and made them the focal point, and others have chosen other career paths that they enjoy. Some have taken foreign travel, and after a period of time, they’ve settled down to other work.

In reading through all the criticisms, it seems the key point these people make is that folks don’t know what the future holds, and so they shouldn’t just “check out” and assume everything will be OK. Health issues, the economy, global war, etc. – all these could impact the future over the next 40+ years.  FIRE folks should continue to work & save “just in case.”

These critics are missing the point. As Joseph Dominguez and Vicki Robin discussed in their epic book (and FIRE bible) Your Money or Your life,  it really is about how much life energy are you willing to expend to acquire something. FIRE folks have made conscious decisions about what matters, and what matters to them is Freedom. Since this is different for everyone, you don’t necessarily need $5M to achieve that Freedom, and you don’t have to stop working at age 35 when you hit FI.

So when you hear folks “Poo Pooing” the FIRE movement, just stop listening – because they just don’t understand (or are unwilling to understand). If folks go into this with full awareness, take control and make conscious decisions on what matters to them, then other folks opinions just don’t matter.

FIRE on folks!

Mr. 39 Months

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.